Important Note: This article is for general information and educational purposes only — not legal advice. It draws on the High Court’s forfeiture judgment in Public Prosecutor v Mohammad Fadino bin Khairuman & Anor, delivered on 23 December 2025, on reports by the New Straits Times and Free Malaysia Today of the High Court’s subsequent ruling on third-party claims on 19 October 2026, and on a LinkedIn commentary by counsel Foong Cheng Leong on 24 October 2026.
For illustration only
What a High Court decision on 176 Bitcoins reveals about recovering cryptocurrency from fraudsters.
In 2015 and 2016, an investment scheme called Bitkingdom promised daily returns of 1 per cent. It collected over 1,000 Bitcoins from hundreds of investors. Then it collapsed.
The individuals behind it were identified, and the cryptocurrency they held was seized. But the case did not end there. When the state forfeits the proceeds of a crime, what happens to the victims whose money was taken? Can they reclaim what was theirs?
In a ruling delivered on 12 October 2026, the High Court answered that question. It ordered the government to return a portion of the seized Bitcoins to nine victims of the scheme. The judgment provides a detailed road map for how victims of cryptocurrency fraud can recover their assets — and why the mechanics of blockchain transactions do not defeat their claims.
The Scheme and the Seizure
The facts are set out in an earlier High Court judgment dated 23 December 2025. The first respondent, Mohammad Fadino bin Khairuman, was the founder and promoter of Bitkingdom. He ran seminars and represented to investors that they could obtain a share of profits from Bitcoin purchased and transferred into the scheme. The second respondent, Arsyan bin Ismail, was the programmer who built and managed the platform — a role the court found went beyond mere employment.
Over time, Bitkingdom collected approximately 1,023 BTC from investors, resulting in losses estimated at over RM44 million. In 2016, the platform converted investors’ holdings into two successive tokens of its own creation — Bitkingdom coin and later Aureus — presented as equivalent in value to Bitcoin. Both proved worthless, and the platform closed in 2018. When the scheme collapsed, 207 police reports were lodged.
Investigations led authorities to two cryptocurrency wallets held with Nexo, a digital asset custodian in the Cayman Islands. The wallets — one held by Fadino, the other by Arsyan — contained 497.82 BTC, valued in November 2023 at approximately US$17.6 million.
In December 2025, Justice Mohd Arief Emran Arifin found that the seized cryptocurrency constituted the proceeds of unlawful activity. The predicate offence was cheating under section 420 of the Penal Code. The court applied the civil standard — the balance of probabilities, not the criminal standard — following the Federal Court’s decision in JJ Power Groups Enterprise & Ors v PP [2025] 7 CLJ 378. It found that the requirements of section 4(1) of the Anti-Money Laundering, Anti-Terrorism Financing and Proceeds of Unlawful Activities Act 2001 (AMLA) were satisfied and ordered the Bitcoins forfeited to the government under section 56(1).
The Victims Step Forward
The forfeiture order did not end the matter. Under section 61 of the AMLA, the court must publish a notice allowing third parties with an interest in the property to come forward and claim it.
Nine individuals did exactly that. They argued that they were victims of the Bitkingdom scheme, that they had deposited their Bitcoins into the platform, and that the seized assets were — at least in part — theirs.
The Public Prosecutor objected. The argument was technical but formidable. The victims could prove they had transferred Bitcoin into the Bitkingdom wallet. But the seized assets were in the Nexo wallets. Between those two points, the cryptocurrency had passed through numerous intermediary addresses, including an online gambling platform, in a process known as “layering.” It was impossible to identify which specific Bitcoin belonged to which investor.
The Public Prosecutor argued that because the funds had been mixed and moved, the victims could not establish a legitimate legal interest in the specific 497.82 BTC that had been seized.
The court also considered whether the claimants had participated in or colluded with the cheating. It found insufficient evidence of that. The nine were treated as victims of the scheme, not participants in it — a finding that cleared the way for their claims.
The Law on Clean Title
Justice Dato’ Indera Mohd Arief Emran Arifin rejected that argument. The core of his reasoning was a fundamental principle of property law: fraud does not confer clean title.
As the judge put it: “Where property is obtained by fraud, the law does not treat the fraudster as acquiring a clean title to it as against the person defrauded.”
The victims were not asserting a debt. They were not claiming that they had lent the Bitcoins to Bitkingdom. They were asserting that the Bitcoins had been obtained from them by cheating, and that the Bitcoins — or whatever now stood in their place — remained theirs. The layering process, however complex, did not extinguish that ownership.
The judge also noted the practical consequence of accepting the Public Prosecutor’s argument. If moving stolen assets through multiple wallets and mixing them with other funds was sufficient to defeat a victim’s claim, then fraudsters could simply launder their proceeds to keep them. The law could not permit such a result.
There was a further point. The Public Prosecutor had relied on the very same tracing evidence to prove that the seized Bitcoins were proceeds of crime in the first place. The court held that the prosecution could not rely on the tracing to establish the offence, and then rely on the complexity of that tracing to deny the victims their claim. A party is not permitted to take both positions in the same proceedings.
The Mathematics of Recovery
While the court accepted that the nine victims had legitimate claims, it could not award them the full amount they had lost.
The nine claimants had deposited a total of 362.04 BTC into the Bitkingdom platform. However, the total losses reported by all investors across the scheme amounted to approximately 1,023 BTC. The authorities had only managed to seize 497.82 BTC.
The court therefore had to distribute the seized assets proportionately. The nine claimants were entitled to a share of the 497.82 BTC that reflected their proportion of the total losses. That calculation resulted in an award of approximately 176.18 BTC — roughly 35 per cent of the total seized amount, distributed among the nine based on what each had individually deposited.
The remaining 321.64 BTC was forfeited to the government. That balance corresponds to the losses of the other Bitkingdom investors — those behind the remaining 198 police reports — who did not bring a claim before the court. Any unclaimed portion ultimately vests in the government. The distribution reflects a practical reality of fraud recovery: when the amount recovered is less than the total amount stolen, victims cannot be made entirely whole. The court’s approach ensures that whatever is recovered is shared fairly among those who come forward, rather than arbitrarily.
The Bitcoins are to be returned in kind, rather than at their original purchase price in Ringgit Malaysia. If the specific Bitcoins are no longer available, the claimants are to receive digital assets or money of equivalent value at the date of transfer.
What This Means for Crypto Investors
The case offers a useful template for victims of cryptocurrency fraud in Malaysia.
First, it confirms that the AMLA framework is not just a tool for the state to seize assets. Section 61 provides a mechanism for victims to reclaim them. Even after a forfeiture order is granted, the door remains open for third parties to establish their claims.
Second, it establishes that layering does not defeat ownership. In the physical world, if stolen jewellery is melted down and mixed with gold, tracing becomes difficult. In the digital world, the movement of funds through multiple wallets is standard practice for scammers. This judgment confirms that the complexity of the blockchain does not provide an automatic shield for fraudsters against restitution claims.
Third, it shows the importance of the evidentiary record. The victims who succeeded did so because the prosecution had already conducted detailed forensic tracing. Where the authorities have used tracing to prove a predicate offence, victims can rely on that same evidence to establish their proprietary interest.
The case is not Malaysia’s first encounter with cryptocurrency in the courts. In The Friendly Loan, the Litecoin, and the Debt the Law Would Not Let Him Collect Twice, the Court of Appeal considered a different question — whether accepting cryptocurrency could discharge a contractual debt. That case turned on contract law; this one turned on tracing and title. Both show the courts adapting established doctrines to a new asset class.
A Closing Thought
The Bitkingdom case involves millions of dollars in digital assets and a sophisticated layering operation. But the legal principle at its core is old and simple: stolen property remains stolen property, even if it changes form or location.
What is new is the application of that principle to decentralised assets. The High Court has shown that the existing legal framework — forged for a world of bank accounts and physical property — is capable of adapting to the digital economy. Fraudsters may be able to move funds across borders and through wallets, but the law retains the tools to trace them and, where possible, return them to the people from whom they were taken.
