Visual Guide
Who Is the Employer? Three Arrangements Compared
Drawn from the Industrial Court’s award in Chin Siang Tean v Great Pyramid Sdn Bhd
Employment arrangements can take different shapes, and the shape determines who the employer is — and which court can hear a dispute when something goes wrong. The three models below are the ones the Industrial Court distinguished in Chin Siang Tean.
Direct Employment
| Who signs the employment contract | The Malaysian employer |
| Who controls the work | The Malaysian employer |
| Who holds the right of dismissal | The Malaysian employer |
| Which court hears a dismissal claim | Industrial Court |
Secondment
| Who signs the employment contract | The original employer |
| Who controls the work | The host company |
| Who holds the right of dismissal | The original employer |
| Which court hears a dismissal claim | Industrial Court |
Employer of Record
| Who signs the employment contract | The Malaysian EOR provider |
| Who controls the work | The foreign client |
| Who holds the right of dismissal | Whoever the court finds is the real employer |
| Which court hears a dismissal claim | Depends on where the real employer sits |
In Chin Siang Tean, the contract pointed to direct employment, but the control pointed to the foreign client. The court found the foreign client was the real employer — and because that employer sat in Singapore, the Industrial Court had no jurisdiction to hear the dismissal claim.
© Justiciable. For general information and educational purposes only — not legal advice.
justiciable.media