Important Note:This article is for general information and educational purposes only — not legal advice. It draws on the Industrial Court award in Chin Siang Tean v Great Pyramid Sdn Bhd [2024] ILJU 237 (Award No. 763 of 2024), delivered by Amrik Singh C on 29 May 2024, and on a report by Free Malaysia Today of the High Court’s decision on 2 October 2026.
For illustration only
What the Industrial Court’s ruling means for Malaysia’s Employer of Record industry — and for employees whose real employer sits offshore
Chin Siang Tean signed an employment contract with a Malaysian company. It paid her salary and issued her termination letter. And yet the Industrial Court found the company was not her employer at all.
Her employer was a Singapore biotech firm that had interviewed her, made her an offer, and directed her work. The employment contract she signed named a different company.
The case centres on a structure that is becoming more common in Malaysia: the Employer of Record (EOR) arrangement. A foreign company wants to manage its Malaysian HR obligations locally but has no Malaysian entity of its own. So it engages an EOR — sometimes through a chain of them — to handle payroll, statutory contributions, and the local employment paperwork. In this case, the Industrial Court found that the Malaysian company that signed Chin’s contract was never her employer, despite that contract.
Chin’s case shows what can happen within that structure. She had a Malaysian contract, a Malaysian company that signed it, and a Malaysian termination letter — and yet no remedy in the Industrial Court, because her real employer sat in Singapore.
The Background
Great Pyramid Sdn Bhd provides outsourced human resource services to international companies. It recruits Malaysians based in Malaysia, carries out HR functions on behalf of the foreign client, and acts as the local payroll vendor.
The foreign company in this case was GenScript Biotech (Singapore) Pte Ltd, a Singapore-based biotech firm. GenScript had no legal establishment in Malaysia, so it engaged its own EOR — Smart Edge Technologies Pte Ltd, also based in Singapore. Smart Edge had no Malaysian establishment either, so it approached Great Pyramid, which could handle payroll, EPF, SOCSO, and statutory deductions for GenScript’s Malaysian-based staff.
The chain ran from GenScript in Singapore, through Smart Edge in Singapore, to Great Pyramid in Kuala Lumpur, and finally to Chin. The agreement between Smart Edge and Great Pyramid would later become a point of contention in the proceedings.
The Two Offer Letters
On 15 October 2021, GenScript issued an offer letter to Chin. The position was Technical Account Manager. The terms were a three-month probation, RM7,000 a month, a one-year contract, a target annual bonus of RM21,000, and fourteen days of annual leave.
Chin signed a Statement of Confidentiality with GenScript on 25 October 2021.
On 29 October 2021, Great Pyramid issued a second offer letter on identical terms. Chin signed it — and signed an Employment Contract with Great Pyramid the same day.
She signed GenScript’s offer letter a few days later, on 1 November 2021.
The sequence is worth noting. She signed the second offer before the first. The court later held that, despite this, she understood the second offer to be a continuation and ratification of the first — not a replacement of it.
The Employment Contract identified Chin as “Staff” and named “Smart Edge Technologies-GenScript” as the “Client” — the entity she was assigned to serve. It also stated that the contract was governed by Malaysian law. At the same time, it contained clauses that pointed elsewhere: annual leave had to be applied for through her superior at GenScript; public holidays followed Singapore’s calendar; medical certificates were to be submitted to GenScript; the termination notice was subject to GenScript’s business requirements; and she was to devote her time and attention to GenScript’s service.
The Termination
The employment began on 3 November 2021. Less than three months later, on 26 January 2022, Great Pyramid issued a termination letter. The reason given was performance: Chin had allegedly failed to respond to customer emails within twenty-four hours.
On the same day, Elise Cheng of GenScript emailed Chin. The email said: “Our local payroll vendor in Malaysia, Great Pyramid, will also be in touch with you this afternoon to inform the same.”
That sentence shows where the decision lay. The decision to terminate came from GenScript. Great Pyramid was relaying it.
What the Industrial Court Found
Chin brought an unfair dismissal claim under section 20(3) of the Industrial Relations Act 1967. Before the court could consider whether the dismissal was with just cause or excuse, it had to decide a prior question: who was the employer?
The court’s analysis rested largely on control. The question was not simply who signed the contract, but who supervised the work, determined leave, conducted appraisals, and made the decision to terminate.
The evidence pointed to GenScript.
Great Pyramid’s CEO, Tejvinder Singh A/L Gurdev Singh, gave evidence. He said he did not know who Chin was until GenScript told him. He was not involved in her day-to-day work. The termination letter was issued on GenScript’s instruction. He could not testify about her performance appraisal, because he had never conducted one — it was entirely within GenScript’s purview.
Work-related emails came from GenScript employees, not from Great Pyramid. And Chin did not report to anyone at Great Pyramid.
The court’s conclusion:
“The fact that the Claimant did not report to anyone within the Company strongly indicates that the Company lacked control over the Claimant’s role and responsibilities and demonstrated no interest in supervising the Claimant as its employee. Consequently, there was never in existence an employer-employee relationship with the Company despite the Employment Contract containing common terms and conditions typical of such contracts.”And:
“The Company did not engage the Claimant under the contract for hire or for reward; rather this role originated and was carried out by GenScript.”
The court also considered, in the alternative, what would follow if Great Pyramid had been the employer. It noted that the Company’s evidence on the performance issue was unrebutted — but it did not decide the case on that basis. The claim was dismissed because the Claimant had failed to prove that Great Pyramid was her employer.
Why the Contract Was Not Enough
The Employment Contract was a Malaysian contract, governed by Malaysian law. Chin had signed it, and Great Pyramid had entered into it. On its face, it looked like an employment relationship — and the court acknowledged as much. It noted that the contract was finalised between the two of them, and that it referred to no other document except the “Client.”
But the contract was not decisive. The court read it alongside the two offer letters and the Statement of Confidentiality, and weighed it against the evidence of how the relationship actually operated. On that evidence, it found that no employment relationship existed.
The Claimant’s counsel relied on Bujang Saat Buang v Dexcel Sdn Bhd & Ors [2010] 1 MELR 152, where an employee was seconded to another company. In a secondment, the original employer remains the employer, and the right of dismissal remains with the employer. The court distinguished that situation. Here, the role originated with GenScript: it was GenScript that interviewed Chin, offered her the position, and set the terms. Chin’s own awareness that GenScript’s offer remained binding on her showed, in the court’s view, that she was not seconded to GenScript. Reading that alongside the rest of the evidence, the court concluded that GenScript was her employer — with Great Pyramid acting as the local payroll vendor.
The Jurisdictional Consequence
Having found that the real employer was GenScript, the Industrial Court faced a further problem. GenScript is a Singapore company. It is not recognised as a Malaysian legal entity.
The Industrial Court’s jurisdiction is statutory. It derives from the Industrial Relations Act 1967, and that Act does not confer extra-territorial jurisdiction. The court’s authority extends to employment relationships within Malaysia — not to disputes with employers outside its reach.
The court cited Hyder Consulting Sdn Bhd v Chan Yau Liang [2008] 1 MELR 76:
“If it is decided that the employer is a local company, then only the court can proceed to determine whether the claimant’s dismissal was with just cause or excuse. If it is the otherwise, the court is not seized with the jurisdiction to hear the dispute.”And from Multicore Solders (M) Sdn Bhd v Yeo Kuei Chwan Donny [2012] 3 MELR 767, as quoted in Wong Wai Che v Quest BPO Sdn Bhd [2021] MELRU 201:
“the Industrial Court ought not to have ruled on the second issue once it had determined that the proper employer was not before the court.”
If the real employer is not before the court, the court cannot decide whether the dismissal was fair. GenScript could not be brought within the court’s jurisdiction. Chin’s claim was dismissed.
The High Court’s Decision
Chin appealed to the High Court — the route now available under section 33(c) of the Industrial Relations Act 1967, in force since 2021. According to Free Malaysia Today, Justice Alice Loke — who now sits in the Court of Appeal — found no grounds to overturn the ruling. She ordered Chin to pay Great Pyramid RM5,000 in costs. Chin has one month from the date of the decision to file a notice of appeal to the Court of Appeal.
The High Court declined to disturb the Industrial Court’s award. But the gap the case exposes remains open. Unless the law changes, an employee whose real employer sits offshore may have no effective remedy in the Industrial Court — even where a Malaysian company signs the contract, pays the salary, and issues the termination letter.
Two Notes on the Award
First, the Claimant did not give evidence. On the day her case was to begin, her counsel told the court she had a home emergency. It emerged that she had taken her cat to a veterinary clinic. The court gave her two opportunities to attend. She did not. The court deemed the case concluded, and her witness statement was never marked or tendered. This meant some of the Company’s evidence went unchallenged. The finding on the real employer did not depend on her evidence — it rested on the documents and on the CEO’s own testimony — but her absence shaped the evidentiary record.
Second, the Claimant’s counsel sought an adverse inference under section 114(g) of the Evidence Act 1950 for the Company’s failure to produce its service agreement with Smart Edge. A summons to produce had been issued. But the court refused the inference. The Claimant had not pleaded the service agreement, had not raised the failure to produce at the hearing, and had not sought an adjournment to obtain it. Nor had counsel shown how the agreement bore on the case. The request was treated as waived.
Practical Takeaways
- For employees: If you work for a foreign company through a Malaysian payroll agent, the identity of your employer may not be as straightforward as your contract suggests. If your real employer is offshore, the Industrial Court may not be able to help you. Before signing such an arrangement, it is worth clarifying which entity holds authority over performance, leave, discipline, and termination — and whether that entity has a Malaysian presence.
- For employment lawyers: The case is a useful illustration of how control is weighed in the EOR context, and of the limits of the Industrial Court’s jurisdiction where the real employer sits offshore. It also shows the importance of pleading a document’s relevance and pursuing it at the hearing where a party seeks an adverse inference under section 114(g).
- For policymakers and regulators: The case exposes a gap in the Industrial Court’s jurisdiction. As EOR arrangements become more common, the position of Malaysian-based employees whose real employer sits offshore may warrant attention.
A Closing Thought
Chin’s claim failed not because her dismissal was fair, but because the Industrial Court could not reach the employer that dismissed her. The court never decided whether the termination was justified. It could not.
That is the gap this case exposes. It does not depend on the conduct of any party. Great Pyramid arranged its business as EOR providers do. GenScript engaged an EOR because it had no Malaysian entity. Chin signed what she was given. None of that mattered. The employer that dismissed her was beyond the court’s jurisdiction.
As cross-border hiring through EOR arrangements grows, so will the number of Malaysian employees whose real employer sits beyond the Industrial Court’s reach. Whether the law will be adjusted to meet them is a question the courts cannot answer alone.
